She Caught Us

I'm 17 and in highschool. This girl I've been crushing on since 4th grade is totally beautiful. Shes on cheer squad, pep squad, plays girls lacrosse, and is perfect in everyway. She has long brown hair past her shoulders, beautiful face, developed an incredible body. I am embarrassingly infatuated with her and she kind of knows it. I do anything she wants, and don't hang around too much, but am around her at school a lot. I have never had the nerve to ask her out anywhere. Every once in a while she will turn towards me in her desk and open up her legs when she has on sheer panties, or sometimes no panties. She has a wonderful dark brown bush between her legs.

Horny and being young, I was in need of sex and couldn't get it, so I went with another guy. I sucked him, he sucked me, and he was the first, and only for now, guy to fuck me. I like getting fucked and using my hand on my self. He says he likes the way my butt muscles clench up when I'm shooting.

We were at his house yesterday after school. He said we were alone and no one would be coming in for a while. His sister walked in, must have heard up in the bedroom and opened the door. My highschool crush was his sister and stood there watching her brother push his big cock in and out of my asshole. She was not shocked, I guess she knew he was gay, but just looked at me and said my name, then "I didn't know about you, I thought you liked girls". I tried to get him off me but he was closed to cumming and while she was standing there he shot in my butt.

I've tried to talk to her, but she won't listen, all she says is "it's ok, you don't owe anyone an explanation". Not only am I embarrassed that the woman I really want to fuck thinks I'm gay, I'm embarrassed that anyone saw me getting fucked. I tried to explain that I wanted to be with her, but she said that wouldn't happen now, not after what she saw her brother doing to me.