Tried Catfishing My Neighbor Which Turned Into Blackmail

Going to try and make a long story short.

I've always had a thing for our neighbor. She's in her late 30s but smoking fucking hot. She's friends with my wife and they jog together on occasion. So one day I try and catfish the husband and to my surprise it was pretty damn easy.

Within a few messages he was sending me dick pics and in less than two days I was getting nudes of his wife! Jackpot right!? Well, not so much. Turns out my wife mentioned to his wife that she had found the alias email on my computer. I always delete everything and keep it on a hidden secure thumb drive but the one time I rush off to work I forgot the extra window I had left open.

Thankfully she didn't find any of the emails or pictures but when the wife shared with the husband the gig was up. Next thing I know the husband I'd been catfishing is demanding pics of my wife. I didn't mind sharing and even agreed to share one pic of my wife for every pic of his.

This went on for awhile and he was even photoshoping our wives naked together. Then he starts bringing up swapping and I let him know that it wasn't option. He starts pushing for a drunk and dark swap. That we'd both get our wives drunk and switch places. Literally just go to eachothers houses.

I keep telling him no but he keeps pushing. Eventually I agree to leave a blind open in the bedroom and let him watch me fuck her. I have a security cam back there and I told him if he tried to film I'd call the cops and report him as a peeping tom.

So I do the deed. I fuck my wife and he's outside watching the whole time. I see in the video that he flips off the camera, whips out his dick and starts jerking it while watching us. Anyways, long story short he offers to return the favor and I turn him down. Telling him all the fun as over and if he kept pushing I'd use the peeping tom video.

He was pretty pissed but so far has let it go. Got in over my head real quick but had some fun at least.

Comments

Anonymous

by Anonymous on Feb 19, 2023 at 12:19 PM


I get why you did what you did to protect yourself but if you were my husband or my husband was in your shoes I would have agreed with your neighbor. I wish you guys at least did the dark drunken swap as an annual occurrence.

(1)  (1)
Anonymous

by Anonymous on Feb 20, 2023 at 12:33 AM

What exactly is catfishing.. but he seemed like a aggressive bully neighbor so who knows what he would hv wanted next hanging over your head so you check mated him good! I can hear his narcissism in his head and aloud when hes alone and sees you lol

(1)  (0)

Comment this

Can't read the image? Click here to refresh