She Said It Was So Small It Didn't Count

My wife and I are in a kinda sort open marriage. Basically if something comes up and she fucks a guy I get one in my pocket. So I get to find a girl to fuck. It's weird to keep count like that but we've only been married 2 years and it works for us. We don't swing or swap often. In fact this is only the 3rd time in our entire relationship.

Anyways, there's this body builder guy at her gym and she asked if she could fuck and I said go for it. They went out Friday and she came home earlier than I expected. She said they went back to his place it was hot and heavey and then he dropped his pants. She said it was so small she thought he wasn't hard until he started putting on this really small condom.

She said they start fucking and he is really into it. Moaning and talking about how sexy she is and she honestly had no idea it was even in. She said it was the size of her pinky and didn't go past her folds (her pussy lips).

It didn't take him long to cum and then turn over. She thought he would atleast go down on her but he didn't even do that. He was lazy and she said he kept farting too.

Anyways, obviously I fucked her to show her was a real man is like and afterwards she said I didn't get one in my pocket because his dick was so small that it didn't count. I laughed and said I'm still getting one. You were naked with another man and he cam from being inside you no matter how small. She laughed and said it has to be a fat girl to make us even.

She said the worse part is going to be finding a new gym. That she didn't want the gym slut award if it wasn't going to be worth it.