Open Marriage Neighbors

Our neighbors Ellie & Andrew moved in across the street from us about two years ago. She was from California he was from Ohio both met at college. Ellie is a spitting image of Lisa Loeb with a very attractive tight bubble ass. Me and the wife are in late forties. My wife still attractive and fit attracts men no matter where we go. The more wine she drank the more she would reveal to my wife how lucky I was etc.Both would say things which gave us the impression they would love to have sex with us. At first it was awkward but we talked about how attractive they both were so we felt honored. We would come home have sex asking the other would we have sex with them It made for hot wild sex. Ten… one night Ellie starts dancing dirty bringing me to the floor showing hand gestures to my bulge making face gestures she would love it . Out of the blue my wife and Andrew disappeared and Ellie takes my hand leads me to a bedroom and starts making outfit with me. It’s unbelievable different from my wife. She whispers are been wanting to be with me and her husband is ok because they have an open relationship. She goes down on me but I just can’t seem to get into the mood. I tell her how hot attractive she is but just need a little more time. I decided to leave and upon entering my house I hear loud moaning sounds coming from my downstairs office. I can’t believe what I’m hearing. Shes talking dirty telling him to fuck her pussy good she’s needed it like that. He ask her.. you like it deep and hard? She says yes she misses it. She can’t even get words out as he’s pumping her hard. She says to keep fucking her hard and then starts to let him know she’s cumming. I listen and can’t believe how good he’s giving to her. I just go back outside and rethink what just happened. Andrew fucked my wife and made her love it. Unfortunately it wasn’t the same experience for me with Ellie. She exits the shower I go in and she ask how was it with an excited face? I say different but good lying to her. I ask her how it went and she just says in a sad sort of face… it wasn’t you but it was ok. Wow she just downplayed what I heard. I couldn’t have ever made her feel the way he did. We kissed and hugged goodnight . What a weird night. The next day we were asked to go out dancing wit other friends and somehow they tag along . We both somehow find our way to the bathroom and I don’t know why but I take a look at his junk and wow! This guy is not a normal guy down there. I can feel the panic starting to build knowing what he gave to my wife. That sort of tool makes a girl fall hard. Was this a setup and I had no idea? Some how the thought of her enjoying him drives me insane and that night I bring it up during sex. I tell her what I saw and she sexually whispers I know he’s big down there. I just control and just cum immediately and she’s just in a sexy whisper encouraging me to cum hard. We played the game and I had the same opportunity she did because Ellie is much attracted to me even still flirts with me constantly making comments on my looks etc. We are both winners in the end … he has a bigger dick but I have the charm and handsome looks.