Straight Female / 34
Dream Or Nightmare Threesome Situation?
This past year I was feeling really lonely and wasn't having any luck connecting with people to date - seems like the asshole switch was flipped on for a lot of guys, so I was turned off by many of the ones I met.
Through a friend, I was introduced to Mike and Tonya, not initially for a threesome but to just know more people in the area I live in and to make friends. They were engaged to be married at that time, and over the weeks we were talking Tonya shared that she wanted to do something wild before they were married, try some things. I made the HUGE mistake of letting those conversations go to places I wasn't fully comfortable with, and before I knew it Tonya was telling me how bored she was with Mike and how she thought a threesome might spice it up. Big. Red. Flag.
On the flip side, I was getting to know Mike better and we got along really well. He was closer to guys I would have dated - slim, nerdy, with glasses that made him look like Rivers Cuomo from Weezer. The more I got to know him, his love of vinyl records and vintage band t-shirts, the more I was confused by how he and Tonya worked. Complete opposites, but I went along with the growing tease that was forming - Tonya was getting to the place where I knew she was going to want to have sex with me, and Mike was oblivious (such a cutie).
They finally asked me over brunch about 9 weeks ago, and we had a threesome. Tonya wanted me to strap-on fuck her while she sucked Mike, and Mike and I made out kind of like a weird Eiffel Tower. That was it, I loved kissing him and something started to stir there. Next time, she wanted me to eat her pussy and she sucked Mike off. I wanted him, too, but was denied. Third time, Mike had to watch the two of us 69, then it was her getting strap on fucked again and sucking him. She said something like he'd probably like that strap-on, and I spent the night back in my apartment masturbating thinking about giving it to him. These threesomes weren't quite what they were cracked up to be - I wanted Mike but Tonya was blocking me! I tried to bring it up with her and she told me Mike didn't feel that way about me and was really just doing all this for Tonya. That sounded off to me, so I texted Mike privately and asked if we could talk. Big mistake, possibly.
That night I ended up pegging him lovingly with an oil handjob and then getting his cute face all in my girlparts for some fun. Mike had no problems with me, Tonya was just being greedy - Mike was wonderful, btw. Perfect gentlemen, took his time, left his cute glasses on. At that point, yep, I had feelings for this man.
About a week later I get a call from Tonya and she cusses me out, calls me every name in the book, and then tells me to come pick up Mike because she kicked him out of their apartment for "cheating" with me. I text Mike, he confirms that he's sitting outside their apartment with all his stuff on the curb. I drive over and start helping him load up into my car, and Tonya comes out and actually tries to attack Mike. Cops were called by the neighbors, Mike was asked if he had a safe place - he did at my place. He didn't press charges, but they were done. And now I have a live-in.
He's lived with me for two months now - wedding's off., needless to say Tonya reveals that she never liked me and that I was terrible in bed, she wanted a gangbang (which she shared that she got after getting rid of 175 lbs of dead weight - classy girl). She also put it out there that I wasn't clean down there AND that I got her drunk and took advantage of her (and Mike was part of that scheme). I am very clean AND would never get someone drunk for sex unless they asked for it. And Mike didn't even know about all this until the brunch. I'm pretty sure Tonya was cheating and used this to seal the deal and get out of her engagement.
So many issues here - one being are we a couple now? Two being if so, how do I tell him no more threesomes? Three being am I a homewrecker? Does that matter if I ended up with a pretty great guy that pays his part of the rent on time, doesn't give me any worry or grief, and is cute as a button and still lets me peg him once or twice a week (I really love doing that)? I mean, my friend group is wrecked at this point, all I have is Mike.
But, I have Mike, so...
Through a friend, I was introduced to Mike and Tonya, not initially for a threesome but to just know more people in the area I live in and to make friends. They were engaged to be married at that time, and over the weeks we were talking Tonya shared that she wanted to do something wild before they were married, try some things. I made the HUGE mistake of letting those conversations go to places I wasn't fully comfortable with, and before I knew it Tonya was telling me how bored she was with Mike and how she thought a threesome might spice it up. Big. Red. Flag.
On the flip side, I was getting to know Mike better and we got along really well. He was closer to guys I would have dated - slim, nerdy, with glasses that made him look like Rivers Cuomo from Weezer. The more I got to know him, his love of vinyl records and vintage band t-shirts, the more I was confused by how he and Tonya worked. Complete opposites, but I went along with the growing tease that was forming - Tonya was getting to the place where I knew she was going to want to have sex with me, and Mike was oblivious (such a cutie).
They finally asked me over brunch about 9 weeks ago, and we had a threesome. Tonya wanted me to strap-on fuck her while she sucked Mike, and Mike and I made out kind of like a weird Eiffel Tower. That was it, I loved kissing him and something started to stir there. Next time, she wanted me to eat her pussy and she sucked Mike off. I wanted him, too, but was denied. Third time, Mike had to watch the two of us 69, then it was her getting strap on fucked again and sucking him. She said something like he'd probably like that strap-on, and I spent the night back in my apartment masturbating thinking about giving it to him. These threesomes weren't quite what they were cracked up to be - I wanted Mike but Tonya was blocking me! I tried to bring it up with her and she told me Mike didn't feel that way about me and was really just doing all this for Tonya. That sounded off to me, so I texted Mike privately and asked if we could talk. Big mistake, possibly.
That night I ended up pegging him lovingly with an oil handjob and then getting his cute face all in my girlparts for some fun. Mike had no problems with me, Tonya was just being greedy - Mike was wonderful, btw. Perfect gentlemen, took his time, left his cute glasses on. At that point, yep, I had feelings for this man.
About a week later I get a call from Tonya and she cusses me out, calls me every name in the book, and then tells me to come pick up Mike because she kicked him out of their apartment for "cheating" with me. I text Mike, he confirms that he's sitting outside their apartment with all his stuff on the curb. I drive over and start helping him load up into my car, and Tonya comes out and actually tries to attack Mike. Cops were called by the neighbors, Mike was asked if he had a safe place - he did at my place. He didn't press charges, but they were done. And now I have a live-in.
He's lived with me for two months now - wedding's off., needless to say Tonya reveals that she never liked me and that I was terrible in bed, she wanted a gangbang (which she shared that she got after getting rid of 175 lbs of dead weight - classy girl). She also put it out there that I wasn't clean down there AND that I got her drunk and took advantage of her (and Mike was part of that scheme). I am very clean AND would never get someone drunk for sex unless they asked for it. And Mike didn't even know about all this until the brunch. I'm pretty sure Tonya was cheating and used this to seal the deal and get out of her engagement.
So many issues here - one being are we a couple now? Two being if so, how do I tell him no more threesomes? Three being am I a homewrecker? Does that matter if I ended up with a pretty great guy that pays his part of the rent on time, doesn't give me any worry or grief, and is cute as a button and still lets me peg him once or twice a week (I really love doing that)? I mean, my friend group is wrecked at this point, all I have is Mike.
But, I have Mike, so...
- That's Juicy! 21
- Remove It! 1
